Timothée Chalamet, Jennifer Garner & More Celebs Who Reacted to Their Own Viral Moments

The moment: Instagram account @Chalametinart Photoshops the actor into works of art 

Host Jimmy Fallon showed the Beautiful Boy star a pair of the classic edited works, Michelangelo’s Boy with a Basket of Fruit and David. “That is so weird,” Chalamet said. “But it’s cool, it’s cool, and I’m grateful for whoever has been doing that, thank you, and thank you for working on that.”

The moment: An adorably sassy photo of a young Cardi B

The rapper posted a hilarious throwback photo of herself at age 5 on Instagram, in which little Belcalis poses with a hand on her hip and an expression on her face like she’s about to tell on the person taking the photo.

Fans latched onto the photo and turned it into a meme — the most popular caption being ‘My momma said ya’ll have to play with me’ — that channeled the spirit of every precocious younger cousin everywhere.

Cardi B herself responded to the meme by reposting the meme on her Instagram account, captioned “Yaaaa annoying for this 😩😩😩😩😂Leave five year old Belcalis alone 😤😤”

However, after reposting a few memes with warnings that fans “need to stop,” she eventually was won over, writing on one particularly precocious meme, “too funny cause i was a smart ass like this.”

The moment: A very shocked Jennifer Garner at the 2018 Oscars

The actress, who became the subject of an unexpected viral meme during the 90th Academy Awards telecast, reacted to the gif of her oh-my-God-epiphany that left everyone wondering: “What realization did Jennifer Garner just come to?”

One day after the ceremony, Garner offered her own theories on her Instagram Story by sharing three responses. “Congrats to Shape of Water! Maybe I should date a fish?” she said, referring to the Guillermo del Toro-directed best picture winner.

“Hey Jimmy Kimmel, what’s in your wallet? Wait where’s my wallet?” Garner said, alluding to the tagline of her popular Capital One Venture television commercials.

And lastly: “Can’t wait to work with Lena Dunham! Wait did I sign a nudity waiver?”

The moment: Winona Ryder’s many animated facial expressions at the 2017 Screen Actors Guild Awards

While accepting the 2017 SAG award for outstanding performance by an ensemble in a drama series for Stranger Things, Ryder made headlines (and inspired many memes) when she reacted to costar David Harbour’s impassioned speech with a variety of facial expressions. 

“She couldn’t hear me!” Harbour told PEOPLE a month later, revealing the real reason Ryder reacted the way she did on stage. “Which I was confused by, because I was screaming! But apparently, she couldn’t hear me.”

The moment: Sharing her 2016 new year resolutions 

In January 2016, Jenner posted a video clip on her YouTube channel, sharing her new year resolutions with her fans. The quote that stuck with viewers? “Like, I feel like every year has a new energy, and I feel like this year is really about, like, the year of just realizing stuff. And everyone around me, we’re all just, like, realizing things.”

While the makeup mogul and new mom hasn’t directly spoken out about her famous quote, it’s clear the reality star is in on the joke. Almost a year later, she added shirts and, eventually, phone cases with “Like, realizing stuff” etched on the front, to her online store.

The moment: Nicole Kidman’s strange clapping at the 2017 Oscars

Kidman’s truly wacky clapping technique was one of the craziest audience reactions of the 2017 Academy Awards — and nearly two weeks after the awards show, Kidman finally explained what prompted her “seal clapping.

Turns out, the actress was being careful with her jewelry. “I was like gosh, I want to clap, I don’t want to not be clapping, which would be worse, right? ‘Why isn’t Nicole clapping?'” Kidman shared during an interview on KISS FM’s Kyle and Jackie O. “So therefore I’m clapping but it was really difficult because I had a huge ring on that was not my own, but it was absolutely gorgeous, and I was terrified of damaging it!”

The moment: The emergence of Demi Lovato’s imaginary twin Poot

After an unflattering photo of Lovato hit the internet in 2015, a Tumblr user circulated the photo, claiming it wasn’t of the singer, but instead of her imaginary twin named Poot, who lived her entire life in a basement. The photo may have sparked a various memes, but Lovato wasn’t amused. “Cool to see a s—ty angle turn into a meme that circulates the internet to people’s amusement ha,” she wrote in a since-deleted tweet that same year. But the singer seems to have changed her tune. She shared a gif of Poot on Twitter in April 2017 to the delight of her fans.

The moment: Michelle Obama doesn’t know where to put Melania Trump’s gift

In one of the most memorable GIFs from Donald Trump’s inauguration, Mrs. Obama awkwardly received current First Lady Melania Trump’s present and frantically looked around for a place to put it. “You brought a gift!” Obama exclaimed as seen and heard on footage of their meeting. “I’ll take care of the protocol here,” the 44th commander-in-chief said gamely.

During her frst interview since leaving the White House in February 2018, Obama recalled her train of thought when she looked around in vain for an aide to hand it off to while they posed for cameras.

“What am I supposed to do with this gift? And everyone cleared out and no one would come and take the box. And I’m thinking do we take the picture with?” the Chicago native told host Ellen DeGeneres.

“And then my husband saved the day – see he grabbed the box and took it back inside. But everybody cleared out. No staff, no one. I was like what do you do with the box?” she added.

The moment: A throwback Taylor Swift photo inspires a “No, it’s Becky” meme

Swifties know the Reputation crooner is always watching — particularly when it comes to Tumblr, fandom blogs and social media — so it came as no surprise when Swift stepped out in 2014 wearing a “No, it’s Becky” shirt, paying tribute to the iconic Tumblr post that features a pic of a teenaged Swift, who is labeled as “Becky” by the poster. A fan recognized the girl in the photo as Swift, writing so in the comments. The original Tumblr user’s reply? You guessed it: “No it’s Becky.” 

The moment: Nick Jonas’ three front teeth

For years the internet has speculated about the singer’s mouth. Pics of the crooner’s open-mouthed smile have circulated, confusing fans who were previously unaware of Jonas’ (maybe) three front teeth.

“I just have kind of messed up teeth if it looks like I have three front teeth,” Jonas told PEOPLE at a 2018 Booking.com event. “So strange the things that people decide to talk about.”

The moment: Kim Kardashian West’s crying face on Keeping Up with the Kardashians

Every one of the KKW Beauty founder’s ugly-cry moments is equally iconic — and Kardashian West is well aware, having sold merchandise that bears her famous expression on her website. In 2017, when a Twitter user asked if son Saint was prone to crying, the reality star was quick to respond while poking fun at her much-buzzed-about expression: “Nope! He’s so good but omg he has my same cry face…. poor guy!”

The moment: Chrissy Teigen’s crying face at the 2015 Golden Globes

Kim Kardashian West isn’t the only celeb with a meme-worthy face. After husband John Legend won a Golden Globe for his and Common’s song “Glory,” featured in Selma, Teigen got emotional — spawning a new meme within minutes. As for her response to all the attention? The Cravings author was quick to embrace it. “It’s been 5 minutes and I’m a meme,” she tweeted, following up the post with a second message, “Sorry I don’t practice my cry face okay.”

The moment: John Legend is compared to Arthur

The internet went into a frenzy when a fan compared Legend to Arthur, the animated aardvark whose TV show was a hit among ’90s kids. But the Grammy winner didn’t seem too impressed. “I hadn’t even heard of this Arthur character til now. Was he around when I was a kid?” he tweeted.